Sample case · Divorce Forecast Report, powered by NATE
How a Utah court would likely rule
Custody, Parent-time, Child support · Salt Lake County
You: Mouse · Your spouse: likely a Gorilla
Example only. Invented couple, illustrative numbers. Legal information, not legal advice.
Topic
Custody
1 What you asked for
Joint, but I have final say in some areas
You told us what feels fair to you. The forecast compares it with what a Utah judge would likely order.
2 How likely you are to get it
Your goal: unlikely.
Most likely: Joint legal custody: major decisions made together (81-9-205) (50%). Utah presumes joint legal custody is in a child's best interest unless abuse, a parent's or child's special needs, distance, or another factor shows otherwise (81-9-205(2)). Working in your favor: your spouse has made major decisions without the other parent; you handled more of the day-to-day parenting.
Where the three positions stand
| Position | What it is | Likelihood |
|---|---|---|
| What you think is fair | Joint, but I have final say in some areas | 15% |
| What you expect your spouse to say | Joint: we decide major issues together | 50% |
| Most likely court outcome | Joint legal custody: major decisions made together (81-9-205) | 50% |
3 How your spouse is likely to react
Your spouse is likely a Gorilla. Meets the ending with force. Protects what's theirs and doesn't back down.
And as a Mouse, watch your own urge: Mice agree too fast. It feels like relief now and often feels like regret six to twelve months later.
Your pairing: A lopsided deal that later unravels. Likely conflict: high.
4 How to avoid a needless fight
Lead with what a judge would likely decide.
- Ask for something inside the likely range
- Settle the parts you already agree on first
- Give your spouse a reason to say yes
- Put it in writing, and take a break before you answer any offer
Options that could reach common ground
- A written list of household standards both homes follow (curfew, movie and game ratings, phone age, dress), with everything else left to each home.
- Each parent decides religious activities during their own time, with major milestones (baptism, confirmation, missions) decided together.
- Name a parenting coordinator as the first step before either parent goes to court on a decision (81-9-203(10)).
- Set a response time (for example, 3 days) for major-decision requests, with silence counting as agreement.
5 The law behind the forecast
What a Utah judge must weigh
- Helps youYour spouse has made major decisions without the other parentUtah Code 81-9-205
- Helps youYou handled more of the day-to-day parentingUtah Code 81-9-204
- Helps youSupport for the children's relationship with the other parentUtah Code 81-9-204
- Helps youSigns of coercive control by your spouseUtah Code 81-9-101, 81-9-204
- Weighs on jointDisagreement in 2 decision areasUtah Code 81-9-205
- Weighs on jointTense but workable communicationUtah Code 81-9-205
Utah case law behind this analysis
Tilleman v. Tilleman, 2024 UT App 54, 549 P.3d 65 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2024)
The trial court applied the joint legal custody presumption, found it rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence (including both parents' inability to co-parent and the father's vexatious abuse reports), and awarded the mother sole legal custody. The Court of Appeals upheld the factual findings but vacated the legal custody award because the trial court treated the general best-interest factors as optional; courts must consider all factors in both the general custody statute and the joint custody statute, though they may weigh them differently.
Why it matters here: The joint legal custody presumption is rebuttable by a preponderance of the evidence, does not apply where there is emotional abuse, and the court must consider every statutory best-interest and joint-custody factor before deciding legal custody.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-10(2), (3), (4) and 30-3-10.2(2) (2021) -> 81-9-204(3)-(4) and 81-9-205(2), (5)
Pusey v. Pusey, 728 P.2d 117 (Utah 1986) (Utah Supreme Court, 1986)
The Utah Supreme Court abandoned the maternal (tender-years) preference and directed courts to decide custody on gender-neutral, function-related factors. It named the identity of the primary caretaker during the marriage as prominent among those factors, along with which parent can provide personal care, where the child has lived pending the decision, and the stability of each home.
Why it matters here: Custody is decided on gender-neutral factors, and prominent among them is which parent was the child's primary caretaker during the marriage.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-10 (1984) -> 81-9-204(4)(l) (primary caretaker factor)
Hinds v. Hinds-Holm, 2022 UT App 13, 505 P.3d 1136 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2022)
The court affirmed sole legal and physical custody to the father in a contest between 'two good parents.' The mother's pattern of interfering with the father's relationship with the child and with parent-time orders supported the father, and the capacity-to-co-parent factor weighed 'very strongly' in his favor.
Why it matters here: A parent's pattern of interfering with the other parent's relationship and parent-time can strongly favor the other parent for custody.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-10(2)(b), (c), 30-3-37(6) -> 81-9-204(4)(c)(ii), 81-9-209
Lerman v. Lerman, 2024 UT App 155 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2024)
The court held that a trial court may not ignore or completely discount a parent's domestic violence just because it was not aimed at the child or did not happen in the child's presence. Here the trial court had weighed the mother's evidence of abuse and explained its decision, so the joint custody award was affirmed; a concurrence urged courts to weigh how intimate partner violence affects co-parenting and the children, citing new 81-9-204(10)(b).
Why it matters here: Domestic violence between the parents must be weighed in custody decisions even if the child was not a target or witness, and it removes the joint legal custody presumption.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-10(2)-(3), 30-3-10.2, 30-3-10.8 (2021) -> 81-9-204(3)(a), (10); 81-9-205(2)(a)(i); 81-9-203 (parenting plan)
Case summaries are plain-English overviews, not yet reviewed by an attorney. Follow each link to read the full opinion.
When you can both see what a judge would likely decide, there's little left to fight about. Most couples can reach a fair agreement together, and anyone can still have an attorney review it.
Topic
Parent-time
1 What you asked for
Mainly with me; spouse has the standard schedule
You told us what feels fair to you. The forecast compares it with what a Utah judge would likely order.
2 How likely you are to get it
Your goal: likely.
Most likely: Mainly with you; your spouse has the standard schedule (81-9-302) (69%). Utah decides physical custody by the child's best interest, weighing factors like the primary caretaker, stability and each parent's availability, with no preference for either parent (81-9-204). Working in your favor: you were the primary caretaker before separating; the children have lived mainly with you since separating.
Where the three positions stand
| Position | What it is | Likelihood |
|---|---|---|
| What you think is fair | Mainly with me; spouse has the standard schedule | 69% |
| What you expect your spouse to say | Equal time | 2% |
| Most likely court outcome | Mainly with you; your spouse has the standard schedule (81-9-302) | 69% |
3 How your spouse is likely to react
Your spouse is likely a Gorilla. Meets the ending with force. Protects what's theirs and doesn't back down.
And as a Mouse, watch your own urge: Mice agree too fast. It feels like relief now and often feels like regret six to twelve months later.
Your pairing: A lopsided deal that later unravels. Likely conflict: high.
4 How to avoid a needless fight
Lead with what a judge would likely decide.
- Ask for something inside the likely range
- Settle the parts you already agree on first
- Give your spouse a reason to say yes
- Put it in writing, and take a break before you answer any offer
Options that could reach common ground
- Give each parent the first chance to watch the children before using a sitter, so time stays with parents (81-9-202(13)).
5 The law behind the forecast
What a Utah judge must weigh
- Helps youYou were the primary caretaker before separatingUtah Code 81-9-204
- Helps youThe children have lived mainly with you since separatingUtah Code 81-9-204
- Helps youAbility to care for the children personally instead of using child careUtah Code 81-9-204, 81-9-202
- Helps youWork-schedule flexibilityUtah Code 81-9-303
- Helps youSupport for the children's relationship with the other parentUtah Code 81-9-204
- Helps youMissed or canceled parent-time since separatingUtah Code 81-9-206
Utah case law behind this analysis
Twitchell v. Twitchell, 2022 UT App 49, 509 P.3d 806 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2022)
The parent-time order fell below the statutory minimum once the child reached kindergarten age, and the trial court did not acknowledge or explain the departure. The Court of Appeals vacated, holding that the statute requires the court to enter the reasons for its parent-time order, which was an independent ground for reversal.
Why it matters here: A parent-time order that departs from the statutory minimum schedule must state the court's reasons.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-34(4), 30-3-35, 30-3-35.5 -> 81-9-206(5), 81-9-302, 81-9-304
Pusey v. Pusey, 728 P.2d 117 (Utah 1986) (Utah Supreme Court, 1986)
The Utah Supreme Court abandoned the maternal (tender-years) preference and directed courts to decide custody on gender-neutral, function-related factors. It named the identity of the primary caretaker during the marriage as prominent among those factors, along with which parent can provide personal care, where the child has lived pending the decision, and the stability of each home.
Why it matters here: Custody is decided on gender-neutral factors, and prominent among them is which parent was the child's primary caretaker during the marriage.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-10 (1984) -> 81-9-204(4)(l) (primary caretaker factor)
Elmer v. Elmer, 776 P.2d 599 (Utah 1989) (Utah Supreme Court, 1989)
The court held that stability and continuity should be weighed according to how long the existing arrangement has lasted and how the child is doing: a few months counts for little, but a long arrangement in which the child has thrived should rarely be disturbed. Where custody was set by stipulation or default, the court may hear best-interest evidence when applying the changed-circumstances test, and findings must show how stability was weighed. It affirmed moving one child to the father, who had actually cared for her (including under a temporary order) for long stretches.
Why it matters here: The weight of the existing custody arrangement depends on its length and on whether the child is thriving in it, and the findings must show how stability was weighed.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-5 / 30-3-10 (1989) -> 81-9-204, 81-9-208
Hinds v. Hinds-Holm, 2022 UT App 13, 505 P.3d 1136 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2022)
The court affirmed sole legal and physical custody to the father in a contest between 'two good parents.' The mother's pattern of interfering with the father's relationship with the child and with parent-time orders supported the father, and the capacity-to-co-parent factor weighed 'very strongly' in his favor.
Why it matters here: A parent's pattern of interfering with the other parent's relationship and parent-time can strongly favor the other parent for custody.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 30-3-10(2)(b), (c), 30-3-37(6) -> 81-9-204(4)(c)(ii), 81-9-209
Case summaries are plain-English overviews, not yet reviewed by an attorney. Follow each link to read the full opinion.
When you can both see what a judge would likely decide, there's little left to fight about. Most couples can reach a fair agreement together, and anyone can still have an attorney review it.
Topic
Child support
1 What you asked for
Your spouse pays you $1,100 a month
You told us what feels fair to you. The forecast compares it with what a Utah judge would likely order.
2 How likely you are to get it
Your amount: likely.
Likely guideline amount: Your spouse pays you $1,320 a month. The chance the order lands within about 10% of this is 88%. Utah presumes the guideline amount is correct unless a court makes specific findings that it would be unjust (81-6-202(2)-(3)). Overnights used: 265 a year with you, based on the schedule a court would most likely order.
How the amount is built
| Line | Per month |
|---|---|
| Income used: you $4,800, your spouse $7,400 | – |
| Base child support (sole physical custody worksheet, 81-6-205) | +$1,135 |
| Half of the children's insurance premium (81-6-208(3)(d)) | −$140 |
| Minimal child care award for children under 13 (81-6-209(5); 81-6-306); can be $0 if no child care is used (to be verified) | +$325 |
| Total | +$1,320 |
Plus means your spouse pays you; minus means you pay your spouse. The base amount is an estimate until the full Utah support table is loaded.
The guideline and the proposals
- Guideline+$1,320
- Your proposal+$1,100
- Your spouse's+$600
| Position | What it is | Likelihood |
|---|---|---|
| What you think is fair | Your spouse pays you $1,100 a month | 70% |
| What you expect your spouse to say | Your spouse pays you $600 a month | 4% |
| Most likely court outcome | Your spouse pays you $1,320 a month | 88% within about 10% |
Extra expenses
| Expense | Your preference |
|---|---|
| Sports, lessons and camps | By income share |
| School fees, supplies and field trips | 50/50 |
| Cell phones and plans | Covered by support |
| A teen's car, insurance and gas | Whoever signs them up |
| Private school or tutoring | Doesn't apply |
| College or a mission | By income share |
The statute does not cover these, so they are usually settled by agreement.
3 How your spouse is likely to react
Your spouse is likely a Gorilla. Meets the ending with force. Protects what's theirs and doesn't back down.
And as a Mouse, watch your own urge: Mice agree too fast. It feels like relief now and often feels like regret six to twelve months later.
Your pairing: A lopsided deal that later unravels. Likely conflict: high.
4 How to avoid a needless fight
Lead with what a judge would likely decide.
- Start from the guideline amount
- Settle the parts you already agree on first
- Give your spouse a reason to say yes
- Put it in writing, and take a break before you answer any offer
Options that could reach common ground
- Use the Utah guideline amount as the base, which a court presumes is correct, and negotiate the extras instead (81-6-202(2)).
- Split extra expenses by income share instead of 50/50, with written approval required above a set amount.
- Alternate the children's tax exemptions by year, conditioned on support being current (81-6-210).
5 The law behind the forecast
What a Utah judge must weigh
- Both parents' gross monthly incomes, from all sources Utah Code 81-6-203
- The number of children and the overnights with each parent Utah Code 81-6-205, 81-6-206
- Half of the children's insurance premium and work-related child care Utah Code 81-6-208, 81-6-209
Utah case law behind this analysis
Davis v. Davis, 2011 UT App 311 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2011)
The trial court ordered the father to pay half of the children's school fees on top of guideline child support. The Court of Appeals reversed that add-on. It held that guideline amounts are presumed correct, and that any order differing from the worksheet by $10 or more is a deviation. A deviation requires a specific finding that applying the guidelines would be unjust, inappropriate, or not in the child's best interest, and none was made.
Why it matters here: Guideline child support is presumptively correct, and any departure (including court-ordered add-ons not authorized by statute) requires express findings that the guideline amount would be unjust, inappropriate, or not in the child's best interest.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 78B-12-210(2)(b), (3), (5)(a) and 78B-12-202 -> now Utah Code 81-6-202(2)-(6)
Merrill v. Merrill, 2024 UT App 125 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2024)
The Court of Appeals affirmed counting the father's vested restricted stock units (RSUs) in his gross income for support. It held that vested stock received for labor falls squarely within the statutory definition of gross income. The party challenging the calculation bears the burden of showing inequity, and merely noting that restrictions apply is not enough. It also affirmed the refusal to impute higher income to the mother, and noted that either party may seek modification if income later changes substantially.
Why it matters here: Gross income for child support includes prospective income from any source, including vested equity compensation such as RSUs, unless the challenging party shows its inclusion is inequitable.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 78B-12-203(1), 78B-12-102(14)(b), 78B-12-203(8)(a), 78B-12-210(9) -> now Utah Code 81-6-203(2), (6) and 81-6-212
Carlson v. Carlson, 584 P.2d 864 (Utah 1978) (Utah Supreme Court, 1978)
The trial court ordered support past age 18, apparently for college. The Utah Supreme Court vacated the order. It held that a parent's support duty normally ends at majority, and that although Utah Code 15-2-1 lets divorce courts order support to age 21, that power is discretionary and must rest on findings of special or unusual circumstances. It noted that parents should not be compelled to fund an adult child's college education except in unusual circumstances.
Why it matters here: Utah courts generally may not require a parent to pay post-majority (college) support; the authority to extend support to age 21 exists only with findings of special or unusual circumstances, so college costs are normally a matter of agreement.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 15-2-1 (support to age 21 in divorce actions; not part of the Title 81 recodification); support termination now governed by Utah Code 81-6-213 (formerly 78B-12-219)
Dole v. Dole, 2018 UT App 195 (Utah Court of Appeals, 2018)
The father argued he was entitled to claim the children because he paid child support and other costs. The Court of Appeals affirmed awarding both exemptions to the mother. The statute creates no presumption favoring either parent and no entitlement based on paying support. It leaves the award to the court's sound discretion, case by case, with each parent's relative contribution to the cost of raising the children as the primary factor and relative tax benefit as another.
Why it matters here: There is no presumption for which parent claims the children; the court decides case by case, weighing primarily each parent's relative contribution to the children's costs and secondarily the relative tax benefit.
Statute then and now: Utah Code 78B-12-217 -> now Utah Code 81-6-210
Case summaries are plain-English overviews, not yet reviewed by an attorney. Follow each link to read the full opinion.
When you can both see what a judge would likely decide, there's little left to fight about. Most couples can reach a fair agreement together, and anyone can still have an attorney review it.